Underground bar where you get a pizza with every drink. Cheap and not pretentious in anyway. Every time you get a drink they give you a ticket for a free personal pizza. Make sure you tip the pizza guy though because he might not get around to giving you one if not. At happy hour you can basically get a beer and a pizza for $5. There is also skiball in the back and they do trivia nights. Most nights its just locals and never too loud.
325 E 14th St, New York, NY 10003, USA